When the NFL announced the 2025 Pro Bowlers earlier this morning, the Buffalo Bills had two players make the roster: QB Josh Allen and LT Dion Dawkins. Perhaps the biggest surprise, however, was who did not make it.

The Buffalo Bills found names from their locker room included on the AFC roster for the Pro Bowl once again in 2025. But in expected and unfortunate fashion, despite the Bills (13-3) being one of the best teams in the NFL this season,

In fact, it's rather unbelievable that the NFL's touchdowns leader did not earn a Pro Bowl selection, and the Buffalo Bills' running back publicly shared his bewilderment on the social media site now known as X.

That’s what Buffalo Bills running back James Cook is likely thinking after Pro Bowl rosters were announced on Thursday. Cook, amid a career year, was named a first-team alternate with Derrick Henry, Joe Mixon and Jonathan Taylor being named starters in the Pro Bowl Games. Following the announcement, Cook took to X and shared the following message.

MIAMI GARDENS, FLORIDA - SEPTEMBER 12: James Cook #4 of the Buffalo Bills scores a touchdown against the Miami Dolphins during the first quarter in the game at Hard Rock Stadium on September 12, 2024 in Miami Gardens, Florida. (Photo by Carmen Mandato/Getty Images) Selections: Connor McGovern, James Cook. Selections: Damar Hamlin.

Although the Bills have one of the best records in the NFL, only two of their players were named to the initial AFC Pro Bowl squad.

Teams have rolled out their Pro Bowl alternates, who will be elevated to the roster if an originally voted player can not participate.

The NFL's interception leader, a 42-touchdown QB and a pair of star rookie WRs didn't make the cut this season.